Demand is Up and Supply is Down

As is typical for this time of year, demand increased a bit at the beginning of August; however, the continuous drop in the active listing inventory is far from ordinary. Inventories have been dropping across the nation and Orange County is no exception. Since March of this year, the active inventory has been steadily dropping. The inventory has shed 2,925 homes since then, a 25% drop. Currently at 8,681 homes, that is far fewer than the 14,348 last year or 17,611 two years ago. So, what’s going on? Prices are down, interest rates are down, affordability is up and demand is up. All of these forces together have been pulling the inventory down. Throw in the fact that discretionary homeowners are only placing their homes on the market if they have to and are motivated to do what it takes to compete in this market. Demand, the number o f new pending sales within the past month, is currently at 3,481, an increase of 165 pending sales within the last two weeks. Last year demand was at 2,940. So, with an increase in demand and a lower inventory, the market has heated up. The expected market time for all of Orange County is currently at 2.5 months, technically a seller’s market. The lower the range, the hotter the market. All ranges below $1 million are pretty hot, but homes priced below $500,000 are sizzling. The expected market time for homes priced between $250,000 and $500,000 is currently at 1.30 months. For detached homes within that range, the expected market time is only 1.02 months. When the expected market time drops to such low levels, sellers are busy sorting through multiple offers and buyers are writing offer after offer with no luck. I have been asked many times why the market is not appreciating given all of the activity. The devil is in the details. Even though the distressed inventory has been dropping and now represents 29.5% of the current active inventory, 50% of current demand is distressed properties. With so many short sales and foreclosures driving demand, these distressed sellers are keeping a lid on any price appreciation. But, don’t misinterpret me. There may be a lid on appreciation, but in the hotter areas and price ranges there is also a lid on price depreciation. Values have fallen significantly since the start of this downturn, fueled by a consistent supply of distressed properties. So, current values have reached affordable levels where it makes sense again to own versus rent. First time home buyer activity has returned with a vengeance as well. Throw in the return of investor activity and it is no wonder that demand has increased this year.

How do the distressed numbers look? First off, the “next wave” of foreclosures that we have been hearing about since the beginning of the year still has not materialized. I have been hearing from industry experts and agents alike that the next wave is still coming. I am certain that they are right to a degree, that the distressed numbers will increase, just not at the great numbers that they are anticipating. The agents on the streets are telling me that they all have pockets full of buyers waiting for the right property to come onto the market and they all would love a “foreclosure deal.” This is where pent up demand really does exist. Any surge in foreclosures would be met with buyers in waiting. We can expect a lot of competition and continued multiple offers for some time to come. There are currently only 2,559 distressed homes on the market, a drop of 57 in the past two weeks. This is the lowest drop in the distressed inventory since February of this year. Could we be reaching a plateau before the overly predicted wave to come? Only time will tell. There are only 299 foreclosures currently on the active market with demand at 590, representing an expected market time of .51 months. That’s correct, two weeks. Foreclosures are so incredibly hot that they can generate 20 plus offers. Yet, only one gets the property. Demand is plentiful, there just is not enough supply. There are 2,260 short sales on the active market with demand at 1,145 and an expected market time of 1.97 months.

If you are a buyer, how should you respond to this market? First, please throw out the notion that there is no competition and that you can write an offer for thousands less than the asking price. The sales to list price ratio for homes priced below $500,000 is 100%. That means that, on average, homes are selling for their full asking price. For all homes in Orange County, the sales to list price ratio is 98%. Remember, homes have already dropped 30% or more in value. As a buyer, do NOT write an offer for 10% or more off of the asking price with a letter detailing that the housing market is currently in a declining market. These buyers feel that the ultimate sales price should reflect a future drop in values. That notion of purchasing is ludicrous. Industry experts and economists cannot accurately determine future prices and are constantly revising their estimates. The values are already highly discounted over the past few years. Arriving at the fair market value includes taking into consideration pending activity, recent sales (within the prior 90 days), property condition, seller motivation and circumstances, location, upgrades, lot size and amenities. To rely on Zillow.com or other online valuation tools is also absurd. These tools only take into consideration property size and sales price, ignoring all of the other factors that are used to arrive at price. There has been a lot of pressure on interest rates to move higher. Gone are the days of interest rates below 5%. As interest rates rise, affordability drops. In purchasing today, the monthly payment is approximately the same as a home purchased later with a drop of 10% in value and a 1% rise in interest rates. These historically low interest rates are not here to stay. How long they remain low is anybody’s guess. Last, buyers should only purchase in today’s market if and only if they plan on living in their home for years to come. In the long run, Orange County housing has proven to be an excellent long term investment. It is also a great place to call “home.”

Orange County Housing Report: The Distressed Inventory is Dropping

The total number of distressed properties, foreclosures and short sales, dropped to its lowest level since December 27, 2007. There are currently 3,724 distressed homes on the active market, 37% off of the peak of 5,950 established in August 2008. The number of active foreclosures has dropped from its November 2008 peak of 1,404 to 529, a 62% drop. It is not just the number of foreclosures that has been dropping; the number of short sales on the active market has dropped by 20% since February, from 4,009 to 3,195. This drop can be directly attributed to much stronger demand for homes priced below $1 million, which accounts for 74% of the active inventory and 95% of demand. Homes above $1 million account for 5% of demand, but 26% of the active inventory. Demand has been incredibly strong in the lower ranges because of two factors: 96% of all distressed properties are found below $1 million; and, jumbo loans, loans above $729,750, are much harder to obtain than conventional loans, loans below that level.

For Orange County, demand, the number of new pending sales over the prior month, increased by an additional 79, now totaling 3,632 and the current height of demand for 2009. Orange County demand has not been at this level since August of 2005, just prior to the beginning of the current cycle. Last year there were 1,092 fewer pending sales, totaling 2,540, 30% less. Two years ago demand was 1,769 fewer, totaling 1,863, 49% less. Three years ago demand was 26% less and totaled 2,701. The recent surge in demand seems to be abating, but this can be attributed to less inventory in the lower ranges. With an expected market time of 1.73 months, the $250,000 to $500,000 range has been incredibly hot and many buyers have written offer after offer with no success. The sales to list price ratio for homes within this range is 100%. So, those buyers looking to scoop up a deal by writing for less than the asking price are, on average, out of luck. The sales to list price ratio for foreclosures within that range is 101%.

The active listing inventory dropped 198 homes in the past two weeks to 10,363. The inventory has not been at these levels since April 2006. At the start of the year the active inventory was at 11,842, 1,479 additional homes compared to today. Last year there were 15,437 homes on the market, 5,074 additional homes compared. Two years ago there were 15,519 homes on the market, 5,156 additional homes. Three years ago there were 11,956 homes on the market, 593 additional homes compared to today. The expected market time dropped from 2.97 months two weeks ago to 2.85 months today. The expected market time last year was at 6.08 months, two years ago it was at 8.33 months, and three years ago it was at 4.43 months. This is the lowest expected market time since October 2005. Total Orange County pending sales continues its surge, reaching record heights for this three and one-half year downturn, totaling 5,733, an 828 home increase over the past month. Last year at this time, total pending sales reached 3,514, 2,219 fewer than today. Two years ago it was at 2,824, 2,909 fewer. Total pending count is different than demand because demand tracks new pending sales over the past month. Total pending count takes into account all pending sales, including those that have been pending for longer than 30-days. The 5,733 tabulation indicates that there will be a surge in sales over the next couple of months.

How should a buyer approach this market? Most buyers have the wrong expectations in approaching the Orange County real estate market. Everybody is acutely aware of the current global recession caused by the financial crunch, so it is understandable that today’s buyers want a deal when buying a home. However, buyers fail to consider two important aspects of the current real estate market: there is tremendous demand for lower priced homes and distressed properties; and, today’s asking prices already reflect a major drop in value. Prices have reached much more affordable levels just as interest rates have dropped to historical lows, the end result, demand not seen prior to the current downturn. So, buyers need to take a litmus test of the market that they are interested in. Buyers can expect multiple offers and even above asking price sales prices for homes priced below $500,000 and distressed homes. The market has heated up considerably for homes priced between $500,000 and $750,000 as well, with an expected market time of 2.49 months. The market is much stronger between $750,000 and $1 million too, with an expected market time of 4.95 months, considered a market in equilibrium. The incredibly hot demand has been underreported and most buyer have to learn the hard way before getting realistic, writing offers below the asking price and losing out on a property or two. Another reality of the current marketplace is the number of hoops lenders will put you through in funding a loan. Buyers will not only put together the initial loan package; more often than not, the lender is going to request additional paperwork during the pending sale process. As of May 1st, the government imposed an additional hurdle which will change the appraisal process. This new process has a very high potential in delaying the close of a pending sale. It is my humble opinion that these additional hurdles are necessary, but should be postponed until the market has healed. It is easy for politicians to make headlines and change the way lending and appraising is processed in the midst of a downturn, but the real fixes need to come when the market is moving on all cylinders.